New York City is commemorating the 40th anniversary of Stonewall by asking wealthy LGBTQ folks to make a "Rainbow Pilgrimage" to the city. (See poster at right.) Meanwhile, the city has refused to fund shelters that serve homeless queer youth. As a statement from Queers for Economic Justice puts it:
The campaign's website encapsulates Stonewall in a nostalgic distant light; a movement of the past now best found in a culture of style, restaurants and hot new clubs that are profiled in the ad campaign. The past violence and homophobia is replaced by the promise of a New York experience akin to Sex In The City. Further denying the violence of that fateful night in June, the Rainbow Pilgrimage describes the West Village as having a "population [that] has matured and neighborhood scene [that] has quieted along with it."The statement goes on to list the many ways low-income, working-class and homeless queer New Yorkers continue to face harassment, discrimination, and violence -- in shelters, in police custody, and in public. But New York City Council members don't think by such trivial details have much to do with the Stonewall anniversary.But that "quiet" has come at a cost to poor and working class queers today.
City officials found little remarkable in using an event associated with violence and resistance as the centerpiece of a marketing campaign.Note that she did not say, "it created the modern LGBT party circuit" or "it created the modern LGBT tourism industry." (Umm... disconnect?) Queers for Economic Justice rightly points out that the way to commemorate Stonewall is to support organizations and efforts that continue in that spirit today. To that end, here are some great causes to support: Of course that doesn't mean we have to mark the Stonewall anniversary in only a somber fashion, or only by donating to these organizations. But I do think it's important to remember, as Jaclyn said in her speech at the Boston Dyke March, that the first Stonewall wasn't a rave -- it was a riot."I don't think it's ironic, I think it's significant," said Christine C. Quinn, the City Council speaker, who is openly gay, at a news conference announcing the campaign. "You know, 40 years ago a group of people said enough was enough. And they struck back against police officers. They struck back against unfair treatment."
"And," she added, "it created the modern L.G.B.T. civil rights movement."
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Commemorate Stonewall with activism, not tourism.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.feministing.com/cgi-bin/movabletype/mt-tb.fcgi/14595
Alright, firstly, wtf. And secondly, lol at "the LGBT party circuit." That's really something. In the broadest way possible, making Stonewall the new tourist trap or city hotspot is all kinds of disrespectful and just makes me raise an eyebrow. Like, really people, come on.
Additionally, it's sex AND the city. AND not IN. ugh. Good comparison though, QEJ =]
We find ourselves at a milestone for our community while celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Stonewall riots. And I couldn't agree more that our celebration should not only include literal celebrations of how far we've come, but that it should also focus on how we can make our community better.
It is extremely saddening that even in New York City funding for shelters for homeless queer youth is being denied. That is more the kind of thing that I would expect to hear from local politicians here in Oklahoma City. It only furthers the necessity for a strong community that can help to take care of its own. Whether that is one large organization (a National Association for the Advancement of Queer People if you will) or several smaller and highly active organizations and outreaches, there is a need for this kind of activism. I would argue that it does not take away from the greater fight for equality in civil rights, rather it can only make us stronger.
But of course don't deny the true celebration of the GLBT movement. We have a lot to celebrate this year, and celebrate we should, but show the pride all year by donating, volunteering, and being active.
To me, the campaign just seems remarkably tacky and disrespectful. Rainbow Pilgrimage? Really?